Another Take on Princesses: Princess Academy by Shannon Hale

Reading List
Written By Rebecca Grabill
Princess Academy by Shannon Hale

Princess Academy by Shannon Hale

Princess Academy by Shannon Hale. Bloomsbury, 2005.

A lovely, character-driven plot with lots of twist and surprises. I haven’t read a Newbery fantasy like this since The Blue Sword/Hero and the Crown. There’s a strong (contemporary) emphasis on justice and diplomacy, but I found it odd that the prince did not marry a mountain girl. I suppose that’d be a whole different story, but for all the societal attitudes against mountain people, the solution of sneaking a non-mountain girl into the Princess Academy seemed to only prove that yes, the snooty city folk are right, a mountain girl never could be queen.

  • The writing is delicious and poetic. Some distance between the narrator (she’s not very poetic), but less than in Midwife’s Apprentice. It works.
  • I would have liked more setting. It’s cloudy and indistinct to me. I see Linder, but the houses and the peoples’ daily lives ... they’re so organized yet so naive. Uneducated yet peaceful, and wise enough to be open to new ideas. It’s just too Utopian to be believed.
  • The subplot of the protagonist feeling useless is stated but never shown in a truly convincing way.
You may also like...
With the BFG Movie Coming and All
With the BFG Movie Coming and All

In honor of a very special day, I thought I'd revive this old post about a book I found, um, intriguing, with some interesting asides...

Witness this!
Witness this!

This book was made up of poems from different points of view and usually in differing and discernible voices all telling one story.

The plot, though ... the story seemed to end at the wrong spot. It ended with...

A Compass of Gold, off to a Good Start: Pullman's Golden Compass
A Compass of Gold, off to a Good Start: Pullman's Golden Compass

The power of a great opening: Pullman’s The Golden Compass begins, “Lyra and her daemon moved through the darkening hall, taking care to keep to one side, out of sight of the kitchen.” We see a bit of each method of creating conflict. We know...

The Gift of Suffering: The Giver by Lois Lowry
The Gift of Suffering: The Giver by Lois Lowry

Lowry opens The Giver with a description of fear and immediately cements the unusualness of the world she’s created as well as giving us insight into the young protagonist, Jonas. She also is so deliciously good at creating a Utopia that seems wonderful, at the start, and only slowly...

How to Build a Mosque
How to Build a Mosque

The intro is sort of dry, but the melding of fiction and nonfiction with fascinating detail on construction held my interest to the end. Yet why was there such a need for bathing? (I know it’s ritual bathing, but the text doesn’t tell me this.) There’s a ton of info on engineering, but not much...

That's Just Plain Nonsense, Eddie: Complete Nonsense of Edward Lear
That's Just Plain Nonsense, Eddie: Complete Nonsense of Edward Lear

Lear was the youngest of 21 children and was brought up by his sister, who cared for him until he was nearly 50. He was an eternal child with “invincible boyishness,” according to the editor. This collection...

Babe, Such a Gallant Pig
Babe, Such a Gallant Pig

The style is hysterically understated and plays off stereotypes of the grumpy farmer and meddlesome wife. I found...

Exquisite Poetry for Two Voices
Exquisite Poetry for Two Voices

This is a Charlotte Zolotow book, which is no surprise. Such lovely language, metaphor, all the poetic devices one learns in school. I don’t read music, but this reads like I imagine music to be read...

Secrets, Platforms, Bizarre Britishisms
Secrets, Platforms, Bizarre Britishisms

Rich and fun fantasy. Ibbotson starts off with quaint Brittishisms, ghosts, and secret doors to other worlds. What’s not to love? Loads of fantastical invention and a heavy dose of political correctness. Atmospheric with a distant 3rd person narrator, similar in voice to others like...

Collection of Poems, linked: Carver: A Life in Poems
Collection of Poems, linked: Carver: A Life in Poems

Would it be admitting ignorance to say I don’t like poems I don’t understand? I mean, I sort of understand “The Perceiving Self,” but I mostly don’t. It makes me wonder...

Rebecca Grabill

Rebecca has been writing since childhood, her first book about a kitten published between homemade cardboard covers in second grade. Although she studied religion and philosophy in university, she continued writing, earning an MFA from Hamline University and publishing multiple picture books (no longer with homemade covers) and a collection of poetry with a variety of New York and independent publishers. She has also published a wide array of fiction, essays, and poetry in magazines and journals and photographs for Getty Images. She balances writing with homeschooling the younger of her six children, launching her young adults, church activities, and overseeing a small flock of chickens in rural West Michigan.

www.rebeccagrabill.com
Previous

Never Trust a Police Dog: Officer Buckle and Gloria by Peggy Rathmann
Next

Like Sitting on a Cloud and Flying: Little Bear by Else Holmelund Minarik